Whack It With a Hammer

Adventures in DIY and Decor

Bathroom, Bathstore, DIY, fixing, Replacing a toilet sesat, Toilet, Uncategorized

Replacing a Toilet Seat (it’s all glamour)

One of life’s great mysteries is ‘who broke the toilet seat?’ Of course this is one of those questions that has no answer because despite the fact that toilet seats get broken all the time, no one will ever, ever own up to it. Of course when this happened in my house I was happy to be the nominated person to replace the toilet seat. I’ve done this before and it took about ten minutes. Turns out not as simple as it used to be.

Most old school seats just unscrew, you screw the new one in quite easily and they have universal fixings. However, if you find yourself in this situation with a modern seat with concealed fixings, like I did with the Bathstore Euro Mono, here are a few handy tips.

Some of the links in this article are affiliate links, so if you choose to buy something I will receive a commission, at no additional cost to you, which will help me keep this site running.

When faced with this do not panic. Just order a replacement part from the Bathstore website and it will arrive the next day. Assume that the fitting instructions will give you a clue how to remove the broken fitting.

Toilet pan with the seat removed but the fixings still attached. Ready to replace the toilet seat.

Do not despair when the part arrives (in a designated one hour slot) with no instructions as there is always a handy video on YouTube to help. We used this one to show us how it goes on and worked out how to take it off.

Top tip from my Dad: Before you start work put and old towel or cloth in the pan in case you drop something. I cannot stress how many times I dropped my screwdriver. This is very good advice (you can look at other projects I’ve done with my dad here and here)

Toilet pan with a folded pink towel inside to catch loose fixings or tools

Top tip from me: Keep wiping down with disinfectant and wear rubber gloves, no matter how much your toilet gets cleaned you’re going to encounter icky stuff.

Now you’re ready to lever off the silver cover and unscrew the fixing underneath, use a flat head screw driver to raise the fitting and create tension otherwise you’ll be turning for hours.

Levering the fixings off with two screw drivers.

Once it’s all off place the new rubber fitting on top and drop the screws into place. When trying to drop the fixings into the holes make sure the wingnut are sat correctly or you’ll never get it in.

nut and wing bolt possitioned correctly.
Bolt and wing nut possitioned incorrectly.

Now you’re ready to screw into place and fit the silver cover on top. Tahdah!

Placing the decorative cover over the fixings. Nearly ready to replace the toilet seat.

All that is left to do is slip the easy fix toilet seat back on. Oh, unless it was bought seven years ago as that won’t fit because either you’ve broken something taking it out or the fixings have changed!

Showing how different the old fitting and new fitting are.

As we are moving house soon I didn’t want to have to buy a new £50 soft close seat like the last one so chose a slightly cheaper version in the same style secure in the knowledge that it was compatible.

So, order a new toilet seat which is definitely compatible and uses the same fitting, look here’s the spare at the bottom of the page!

Realise its Friday so the seat won’t come until Monday. Have a weekend of cold bottoms.

(no appropriate photo for this I’m afraid)

What I didn’t realise then but know now is that you don’t have to go to the original retailer, there are is much more choice available that will also fit.

Monday, and the new seat is delivered! Here’s the obligatory gurning photo…

Face of womand (me) gurning through a toilet seat.

But wait a minute, the fixings don’t even remotely match!

New toilet seat with plastic fittings.

Luckily, this seat came with instructions which are super simple.

Plastic plug going into the hole or the toilet pan.
Push the plug in.
close of screw and plastic washer being fitted.
Place fitting, washer and screw in the hole.
plastic fixings fitted in place with two screws. Fixings ready to replace the seat.
Screw into place and slide the seat on.

So, what is the main thing I’ve learnt from this exercise? Well, the cheaper the toilet seat the easier it is to replace.

Fixed Euro Mono Bathstore with replaced toilet seat.

Bye, bye cold bums!

(that’s our bums, I’m not calling you a cold bum, that would be rude.)

If you enjoyed reading this please follow me – you’ll just get blogs no spamming! Or to share ideas and inspiration follow me on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter or Pinterest.


  1. Martyn

    November 29, 2018 at 11:17 am

    Great tips and good helpful fun post

  2. Kate

    November 29, 2018 at 11:43 pm

    This was a timely post as I recently broke my parents’ toilet seat! It was out of alignment and I tried to fix it myself, which only made the problem worse.

  3. Penny

    November 30, 2018 at 12:44 am

    I’m so DIY phobic I’d probably (and v embarrassingly for a 30 year old) ask my parents to fix it if this happened to me! The shame!

  4. Will

    May 14, 2020 at 1:18 pm

    Hi Natalie, I’d almost lost hope of finding a replacement seat for my two euro mono back to wall toilets (from Bathstore which discontinued the seats) both of which have cracked over the years and then I saw your post from 2018:
    Please can you tell me the model/make of toilet seat you found which fits the base I have? I couldn’t find a link on your post and don’t know where to start looking. Grateful for any info you can remember!
    Thanks, Will

    1. Whackitnat

      November 6, 2020 at 1:23 pm

      Sorry for the delay, I had taken a break from blogging. They have now stopped selling the one I used but any of the D shaped ones should fit. Good luck!

Leave a Reply